Compare commits

...

1 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
devin
c7a9719f6e decomp: emission gates for iplSDChannelTitle + MemoryCardManager decodes
IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP gates move inline members to declarations so the
TU emits non-inlined calls like retail (same dedup-loss pattern as
#834's vtable restoration): iplInterporation::get, math::VEC3 ctor,
FaderSceneBase::initCalcNormal/calcCommonAfter, SceneBase::isReady/
isResetProcessDone/getParent/getChild/getNext/getPrev, NANDTask::
isFinished/checkData, Graphics::setOrthoTrans/setOrthoScale,
ut::Rect/RuntimeTypeInfo.

Verified vs main: iplSDChannelTitle 68/69 fns byte-exact (152B tail
residual in iplSDChannelTitle_flushSaveBeforeExit), iplMemoryCardManager
18/26. Units stay NonMatching; documented walls in revisit.attempts.md.

Co-authored-by: coah80 <usernamecole7@gmail.com>
Co-Authored-By: wch <usernamecole7@gmail.com>
2026-10-02 22:20:21 +00:00
11 changed files with 176 additions and 18 deletions

View File

@@ -163,6 +163,9 @@ namespace ipl {
void init(const f32& start, const f32& end, f32 maxFrame, f32 startTangent, f32 endTangent, int playback = ANIM_TYPE_FORWARD,
f32 speed = 1.0f);
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
f32 get() const;
#else
f32 get() const {
f32 var_f27 = mFrame;
f32 var_f28 = 1.0f / mMaxFrame;
@@ -181,6 +184,7 @@ namespace ipl {
return r;
}
#endif
protected:
f32 mStart;

View File

@@ -103,7 +103,7 @@ namespace ipl {
y = r.y;
z = 0.0f;
}
#if defined(IPL_ADDRESS_EDIT_CPP) || defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_SELECT_CPP) || defined(IPL_GC_WINDOW_CPP)
#if defined(IPL_ADDRESS_EDIT_CPP) || defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_SELECT_CPP) || defined(IPL_GC_WINDOW_CPP) || defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP)
VEC3(f32 fx, f32 fy, f32 fz);
#else
VEC3(f32 fx, f32 fy, f32 fz) {

View File

@@ -31,8 +31,12 @@ namespace ipl {
virtual void calc();
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual void initCalcNormal();
#else
virtual void initCalcNormal() {
} // 0x4C
#endif
virtual void initCalcFadeout() {
} // 0x50
@@ -49,8 +53,12 @@ namespace ipl {
return FADER_SCN_NEXT;
} // 0x60
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual void calcCommonAfter();
#else
virtual void calcCommonAfter() {
} // 0x64
#endif
int getSceneFadeState() {
return mScnFadeState;

View File

@@ -62,7 +62,11 @@ namespace ipl {
virtual ~Base();
/** @brief If the scene is ready */
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual BOOL isReady() const;
#else
virtual BOOL isReady() const { return FALSE; }
#endif
/** @brief If the user can power off/reset the system */
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
@@ -73,7 +77,11 @@ namespace ipl {
/** @brief The scene running code when powering off/resetting the system */
virtual void startResetting() {}
/** @brief If the scene has finished its powering off/resetting task */
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual BOOL isResetProcessDone();
#else
virtual BOOL isResetProcessDone() { return TRUE; }
#endif
/** @brief Prepare to create scene */
virtual void prepare() {}
@@ -86,10 +94,17 @@ namespace ipl {
/** @brief Destroy the scene and clear from memory */
virtual void destroy() {}
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual Base* getParent();
virtual Base* getChild();
virtual Base* getNext();
virtual Base* getPrev();
#else
virtual Base* getParent() { return (Base*)mpParent; }
virtual Base* getChild() { return (Base*)mpChild; }
virtual Base* getNext() { return (Base*)mpNext; }
virtual Base* getPrev() { return (Base*)mpPrev; }
#endif
/** @brief Check if scene has been created.*/
bool isSceneCreated() const { return (mScnState & SCN_STATE_CREATED); }

View File

@@ -65,8 +65,13 @@ namespace ipl {
/** @brief Writes the file contents. */
virtual void write(); // 0x10
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
virtual bool isFinished();
virtual int checkData();
#else
virtual bool isFinished() { return mbDoneTask; } // 0x14
virtual int checkData() { return mResult; } // 0x18
#endif
virtual bool isFatalError(); // 0x1C
u8* getBuffer() const { return mpBuffer; }

View File

@@ -51,12 +51,17 @@ namespace ipl {
mArg.mOrthoScale = scale;
}
#ifdef IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP
static void setOrthoTrans(const math::VEC3& translate);
static void setOrthoScale(const math::VEC2& scale);
#else
static void setOrthoTrans(const math::VEC3& translate) { mArg.mOrthoTrans = translate; }
static void setOrthoScale(const math::VEC2& scale) NO_INLINE {
mArg.mOrthoScale.x = scale.x;
mArg.mOrthoScale.y = scale.y;
}
#endif
private:
static Arg mArg;

View File

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ namespace nw4r {
namespace ut {
class Rect {
public:
#ifdef IPL_SOUND_RECT_OUT_OF_LINE
#if defined(IPL_SOUND_RECT_OUT_OF_LINE) || defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP)
Rect();
#else
Rect() : left(), top(), right(), bottom() {}
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ namespace nw4r {
Rect(f32 l, f32 t, f32 r, f32 b) : left(l), top(t), right(r), bottom(b) {}
#endif
#if !defined(IPL_CONTROLLER_TRIVIAL_RECT_DTOR) && !defined(IPL_MEMORYCARD_BASE_CPP)
#if !defined(IPL_CONTROLLER_TRIVIAL_RECT_DTOR) && !defined(IPL_MEMORYCARD_BASE_CPP) && !defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP)
~Rect() {}
#endif

View File

@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ namespace nw4r {
} // namespace detail
template <typename TDerived, typename TBase>
#if defined(IPL_BOARD_OBJECT_EXTERNAL_DYNAMIC_CAST) || defined(IPL_MEMORYCARD_BASE_CPP)
#if defined(IPL_BOARD_OBJECT_EXTERNAL_DYNAMIC_CAST) || defined(IPL_MEMORYCARD_BASE_CPP) || defined(IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP)
TDerived DynamicCast(TBase* pPtr);
#else
inline TDerived DynamicCast(TBase* pPtr) {

View File

@@ -237,10 +237,7 @@ bool MemoryCardManager::isIconValidate(u8 slot, s16 index) {
bool MemoryCardManager::isBannerEnable(u8 slot, s16 index) {
CardIcons* icons = reinterpret_cast<CardIcons*>(memorycard::getIconStateArray());
u32 file = mFile[slot][index].fileNo;
memorycard::IconState* icon = &icons[slot][file];
u8 enabled = icon->bannerEnable;
return enabled != 0;
return icons[slot][mFile[slot][index].fileNo].bannerEnable != 0;
}
void MemoryCardManager::update_icon_anm() {

View File

@@ -3,6 +3,10 @@
#define IPL_SDMEMORY_DIALOG_STATE_ACCESSOR
#define IPL_SDMEMORY_COMPLETION_PCT_ACCESSOR
#define IPL_CHANNEL_TITLE_NOVTABLE
#include "math/iplInterporation.h"
#undef IPL_CHANNEL_TITLE_NOVTABLE
#include "scene/sdChannelTitle/iplSDChannelTitle.h"
#include "scene/sdChannelSelect/iplSDChannelSelect.h"
#include "system/iplSystem.h"
@@ -1554,15 +1558,5 @@ void SDChannelTitle::startResetting() {
snd::getSystem()->resetAllSound();
}
extern "C" void iplSDChannelTitle_onTitleButtonEvent(SDTitleButtonEventHandler* handler, u32 component,
u32 event, const controller::Interface* controller) {
handler->onEventDerived(component, event, controller);
}
extern "C" void iplSDChannelTitle_onTitlePaneEvent(SDTitlePaneEventHandler* handler, u32 component,
u32 event, const controller::Interface* controller) {
handler->onEvent(component, event, const_cast<controller::Interface*>(controller));
}
}
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,130 @@
# revisit leaf — second-pass evidence (agent/w1007/revisit @ origin/main 29fe1efa)
Scope: iplSDChannelTitle (99.98883), ut_ArchiveFontBase (98.52), lyt_window (99.76),
iplMemoryCardManager (97.88). Post-#834 (linkgap emit gates + .data object names).
## iplSDChannelTitle — all gates landed
Per-TU `IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP` declared-only gates applied to:
RuntimeTypeInfo.h DynamicCast, iplMathTypes.h VEC3 3-arg ctor, GUIManager.h
(EventHandler setManager/setLatestEventCtrlNo/getLatestEventCtrlNo,
Component setTriggerTarget, PaneComponent setPane/getPane), iplGraphics.h
setOrthoTrans/setOrthoScale, iplSceneBase.h isReady/isResetProcessDone/getParent/
getChild/getNext/getPrev, iplFaderSceneBase.h initCalcNormal/calcCommonAfter,
iplNand.h File::isFinished/checkData, iplInterporation.h HermiteIntp<f32>::get
(nested under IPL_CHANNEL_TITLE_NOVTABLE spec), Rect.h 0-arg ctor
(IPL_SOUND_RECT_OUT_OF_LINE gate), iplGuiManager.h ~PaneManager.
Deleted 2 unreferenced extern "C" trampolines (onTitleButtonEvent/onTitlePaneEvent)
orig lacks. Result: all data sections 100%; .text 99.98883.
### VERIFIED WALL — dtor emission policy (decl-immune)
Residual .text gap = 2 unreferenced weak deleting-dtor bodies
(~FaderSceneBase 88B + ~FrameController 64B) + ~5 dangling no-reloc UNDs
(__vt__LangFile, __vt__SDButtonEventHandlerBase, __vt__FrameController,
mArg/typeInfo syms — symtab noise, no relocs). Orig's TU had these dtors
trivial/implicit: ~SDChannelTitle calls ~Base directly (28 insns), Rect
temporaries carry no dtor calls, so correct forms are `virtual ~X() {}`
inline or NO decl at all. Declaring them out-of-line adds real `bl` calls →
fuzzy dropped 99.98883→99.55799. Implicit/non-virtual variants still emit the
weak bodies AND slightly regress — front-end-level MWCC instantiation drag,
no decl form eliminates it. Remaining fn wall: flushSaveBeforeExit 98.59 —
&smArg materialization register choice (orig r3→scratch r4, mine r4/r5→recv-first);
8+ source forms all shift the home, never to r3.
## ut_ArchiveFontBase — ConstructOpAnalyzeGLGR 92.09 (956B)
20 normalized diffs, insns 116-147 of 239 — issue-order inside the
ready-set around the CalcOffsetSheetFlags/CalcSizeFlagSet scratch math.
Orig hoists lhz 0x1c (sheetGlyphCount) / lhz 0x24 (sheetCount) / lhz 0xe
(dataBlockCount) + lwz 0x4c(r20) into the marshal block.
FAILED variants: decl-order swap of the three u16s (identical 20 diffs —
scheduler ignores decl order); moving ctx->m* tail stores adjacent to the
u16 loads (regressed 20→108, whole-web rotation). Conclusion: pure list-
scheduling tie, same family as before.
## lyt_window — DrawFrame 98.18 (1504B)
376=376 insns. One callee-window permutation: orig numbers the static
flipInfos[] array base early (r21, first materialized at insn 36) pushing
arg webs to r27-r31; mine puts it deepest (r31), args r26-r30. Same web
count (12 callee webs r20-r31 both), identical prologue/epilogue; only the
allocator's numbering differs. Plus a repeated stfsx/fadds store-weave in
the 4 DRAW_QUAD_FOR_FRAME_1 corner blocks.
FAILED variants: scoping polPt/polSize inside the macro (385 insns,
worse); moving texSize decl after polPt/polSize (372 insns, worse).
NOTE: paired-single ops — capstone can't decode psq_*/ps_* insns, so
ndiff.py/disasm_fn.py truncate at the first one; use raw-word diffs.
## iplMemoryCardManager — 8 sub-100 fns all decomposed
- isMoveEnable/isCopyEnable (99.83), update_file_array (99.72),
getComment (98.94): 0 normalized diffs — pure regname webs.
- isBannerEnable (92.31, 26 insns, 7 diffs) + getBlocks (92.0, 25 insns,
6 diffs): single diff = `addi r11,r1,0x20` restgpr-setup placement —
orig emits it at tail (after the full member-chain load), mine hoists
to slot 11. Folded-return variant (`return icons[slot][mFile..]` no
locals) emits identical code — scheduler-internal, decl-form insensitive.
Folded form kept (same output, terser).
- _create_icon (87.55) + create_banner (90.42): `(base+const)+var`
member-chain regroup — orig computes (&mFileCell + memberOffs) +
(slot*row + file*0x15C combined index) with `this+0x10EC`/`this+0x110C`
bases cached in callee regs reused across both GX_TF branches, and
rematerializes &cell.icon per call (`add r3,...` then `add r24,...`
post-bl) while mine pins it; marshal order `li r4,0` before `mr r3`
in orig. FAILED variants: `MCFileCell* cell = &mFileCell[slot][file]`
(90 insns — MWCC folded the pointer, worse); `mFileCell[0] +
slot*0x7F + file` flat-index (89 insns — aggressive CSE, worse).
Same documented mcard2 wall.
All units stay NonMatching — no shims, no flips. Every residual is a
verified allocator/scheduler/emission-policy tie with source-form evidence.
## Round 2 (post-#834 rebase @11c75ddb) — sdChannelTitle emit-parity probe
Investigated per orchestrator hint whether the 152B weak-dtor + dangling-UND
residual was the same dedup-loss family as channelTitle's symbols.txt fix.
VERDICT: NOT a naming issue and NOT a flip blocker.
- orig iplSDChannelTitle.o: ZERO weak FUNC syms. Mine emits 2 unreferenced
weak deleting-dtor bodies: `__dt__FaderSceneBase` (88B @0x1f4) +
`__dt__FrameController` (64B @0xb30), plus 3 zero-reloc UND vtable refs
(`__vt__FrameController`, `__vt__SDButtonEventHandlerBase`, `__vt__LangFile`).
- orig iplFaderSceneBase.o's own view: `~FaderSceneBase` is DECLARED-ONLY
(its `__dt__` is UND there, defined in another TU).
- Tried `__declspec(novtable)` on all 4 classes under
IPL_SD_CHANNEL_TITLE_CPP: removed the 3 dangling `__vt__` UNDs (correct
mechanism — orig stores only most-derived vt) but weak bodies persisted.
- Tried implicit-trivial dtor (removing decl): `__dt__FrameController` emit
STOPPED (64B gone), but `calc()` vtable slot shifted 0x0c→0x08 →
calcFadein/calcFadeout single-word diffs (`lwz r12,0x0c(r12)` vs 0x08)
→ REVERTED everything.
- CRITICAL PROOF these bodies are harmless: main's iplChannelTitle.o
(unit fuzzy 100.0 post-#834) emits the IDENTICAL `__dt__FaderSceneBase`
88B + `__dt__FrameController` 64B weak bodies that orig's .o lacks.
They are linker-stripped dead emission; objdiff fn-pairing ignores them.
=> The 152B was never the blocker. Real residual = flushSaveBeforeExit
98.59 only.
## flushSaveBeforeExit — 6-diff → 2-diff minimum
Window is the `sm` (System globals) base web: orig binds &sm to r3 and
loads +0x94→r4 (store), +0x28→r4 (heap arg), +0x94→r3 (recv); mine binds
r4 and marshals recv before arg. Variants:
- saveHeap decl hoisted above getSDPrevPage store: 2 diffs (base→r5,
+0x28 load moved early) — closer but not orig's order.
- `flushAsync(System::getMem2App())` inline: same 2 diffs, base→r4.
Residual = base-web home + marshal eval order — allocator tie.
## GLGR — ready-set issue-order re-probes
- def-move (sheetGlyphCount/dataBlockCount to tail): 20→99 diffs, REGRESSION.
- `u32 remWorkSpace = ctx->remWorkSpace()` hoist: 20→25, REGRESSION.
- stepSheetFlags after flagsSheetsOff (dependency-chain reorder): identical
20 diffs — MWCC issue-order insensitive to stmt order here. Wall stands.
## DrawFrame / MCManager re-verified
DrawFrame 376=376: flipInfos base pinned r21(orig)/r31(mine) + stfsx weave
— callee-numbering tie unchanged. create_banner/_create_icon: `(base+const)
+var` regroup + recompute-vs-CSE (`add r3,r29,r25` remat per call in orig)
— same documented wall.